The Justice of Nur ad-Din Zangi [teacher of Salahuddin Ayubi (r.a)] By Sheikh Zahir Mahmood Please note for those who assume he is asking the dead: He said "Only if you were alive", he didnt ask him directly [which would obviously be wrong]. He said it as respect. e.g. When you see your dead mothers coat, and you say, i wish you were alive, that does not mean you are comitting shirk it just means you miss that person. Allah knows best. Brought to you by the Ink of scholars channel. Youtube: http://www.youtube.com/inkofscholars Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/inkofscholars